Medico-legal or forensic or coroners autopsies seek to find the cause and manner of death and to identify the decedent. Disclaimer: These codes may not be the most recent version. See additional information. Sign up for our free summaries and get the latest delivered directly to you. Our doctors define difficult medical language in easy-to-understand explanations of over 19,000 medical terms. Sajid MI. [QxMD MEDLINE Link]. Subsequent studies have shown surprisingly little change in these rates with time, N Engl J Med. Fail not herein, as you will answer the contrary at your peril. Goldman L, Sayson R, Robbins S, Cohn LH, Bettmann M, Weisberg M. The value of the autopsy in three medical eras. WebWe perform medical autopsies for MUSC Hospital and other referring hospitals, such as Trident Regional Medical Center and the Charleston VA Hospital and medicolegal forensic Kim A Collins, MD, FCAP Medical Director of Tissue Division, Sharing Hope SC (formerly LifePoint) Organ and Tissue Donation Services for South Carolina; Forensic Pathologist, Newberry Pathology Group, Newberry Memorial Hospital; Medical Director, LifeHope Laboratories It can seem like a rude and insensitive request, and it comes, of necessity, at an extremely difficult time.

This website also contains material copyrighted by 3rd parties. [QxMD MEDLINE Link]. Hunter M. Medical research under threat after Alder Hey scandal.

autopsy fermariello The topic of autopsy may be equally awkward for the family of the deceased. Form of warrant in case of wilful killing. [17, 18, 19] although at least some authors have questioned the methodology of those studies. Medical Review:Adam Husney MD - Family Medicine & Martin J. Gabica MD - Family Medicine. Coroner's power to issue subpoena duces tecum. The importance of clear communication about tissue disposition is dramatically illustrated by the organ retention scandal in several hospitals in the United Kingdom. Waseta versus the New Mexico Office of the Medical Investigator, http://www.cap.org/apps/docs/committees/autopsy/requesting_consent.doc, http://www.hindustantimes.com/News/maldives/Maldives-conducts-autopsy-to-examine-dissident-s-death/Article1-217312.aspx#, http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/article6140789.ece, http://masscases.com/cases/app/51/51massappct297.html, National Association of Medical Examiners, United States and Canadian Academy of Pathology.

This lack of enthusiasm for performing autopsies combined with the more immediate demands of signing out surgical pathology and cytology specimens often translates into delayed autopsy reports. [28]. Record of body long dead and buried or improperly kept. Sinard JH. MedicineNet does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. Arch Pathol Lab Med. October 2020 by when is an autopsy required by law in south carolina (A) In addition to the powers vested in other law enforcement officials to order an autopsy, the coroner or medical examiner is authorized to determine that an autopsy be made. Such procedures fit neatly into a physician's mission of improving and prolonging the lives of patients. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed. Am J Med. Turnbull A, Martin J, Osborn M. The death of autopsy?. [5]. AUTOPSIES, PRELIMINARY EXAMINATIONS AND INQUESTS. You're all set! Gardner R, Peskin L, Katz JL. Coroners or solicitors shall order autopsies; autopsy to be ordered upon death of persons in penal institutions. [20], It seems clear that despite advances in medical technology and medical imaging, the autopsy still provides diagnostic information that cannot be obtained by any other means. The original inquisition and evidence, as taken by him, shall be returned by the coroner within ten days next after the finding thereof to the clerk of the court of general sessions for the county in which it was found. for less than 24 hours, or if a person dies from an injury, such as an automobile accident.

JAMA. WebFor Additional Information. , Drastic step: Insurance Department takes action, Japan police arrest 2 in food prank at beef bowl, Russian businessman back after fleeing house arrest, Circle back: Maine claims biggest ice disk, at 1,776, Spoon spotted: Arizona Dairy Queens big red spoon, No April Fools prank: Jogger has close encounter, NY patients ambulance joyride ends when police spike, Officers arrest alligator walking near Tampa Bay, Arizona Dairy Queen on the hunt for missing red spoon, Police search for tiger stolen from home in northern, Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information. The downward trend is well-known its been studied for years. Inquiry in case of suicide.


250(9):1161-4. If that were the case, postmortem studies (autopsies) would be necessary in all deaths. In order for families, the medical profession, and society to realize the considerable potential benefits of a renewed interest in the autopsy, pathologists have to take an active role: by consulting with our clinical colleagues, by providing informative and timely preliminary and final autopsy reports, by participating in collaborative conferences for the attending physicians and house staff, and by supporting efforts by professional organizations to lobby the government for changes that will help reverse decades of neglect. SECTION 17-7-210. And the benefits to the family, the medical community, and the community at large (although very real) may not be immediately apparent. [QxMD MEDLINE Link]. Phone: (843) 792-3500. STLT Collaboration Space. Coroners/Medical Examiners are employed by the government. Any person violating a subpoena duces tecum issued pursuant to this section may be punished for contempt as provided by Section 17-7-190. October 2020 by when is an autopsy required by law in south carolina [QxMD MEDLINE Link]. If the proof shall be that the death was occasioned by the hands of another the conclusion shall be: "That J K, the said E F, by misfortune and contrary to his will, in manner and form aforesaid, did kill and slay.". Findings on preliminary examination and filing of evidence. 2001 Jun. Coroner shall take testimony in writing and bind over or commit witnesses. [14, 15], Cabot, in his landmark paper of 1912, demonstrated what he characterized as a humbling rate of discrepancy between premortem diagnoses and anatomic diagnoses found at autopsy. For example, in Turnbull A, Osborn M, Nicholas N. Hospital autopsy: endangered or extinct?. Exp Mol Pathol. 2600 Bull Street | Columbia, SC 29201 . Cabot RC. Whenever any county, state or municipal law enforcement agency transports a human body to a medical facility for autopsy or other medical examination to determine the cause of death, the law enforcement agency which ordered such medical examination shall provide for the return transportation of the body to the next of kin of the deceased if they reside within the State. The breastbone and ribs are also usually put back. Such arrangements must be made by the next of kin and usually involve a fee for the transport of the remains (if necessary) and the performance of the autopsy. Penalty for burying body without notice or inquiry. Every coroner or other official responsible for performing the duties of coroner shall examine the body within eight hours of death of any driver and any pedestrian, sixteen years old or older, who dies within four hours of a motor vehicle accident or any swimmer or boat occupant who dies within four hours of a boating accident, and take or cause to have taken by a qualified person such blood or other fluids of the victim as are necessary to a determination of the presence and percentages of alcohol or drugs. A little-known S.C. law, on the books for nearly a decade, exempts the state from performing an autopsy on a death-row inmate who has been executed. Insurers dont pay for them. [The high autopsy rate in Vienna] [German]. Procedures to be followed by person directed to summon jury; compensation. deceased person's next of kin must give permission for an autopsy to be MedTerms medical dictionary is the medical terminology for MedicineNet.com. SECTION 17-7-630. Clayton SA, Sivak SL. Richter emphasized last week that the legal team has no evidence connecting the death in any way to Buster Murdaugh, who has recently denied any involvement amid claims that he called baseless. Harold Sanchez, MD, FCAP Assistant Professor of Pathology, Yale University School of Medicine Medscape Education. The coroner may issue warrants, summon witnesses and examine before the jury any person present, whether summoned or not, concerning the death. The notice of hearing shall be served at least four days prior to the inquest. Email Updates. The report was harshly critical of the state of US schools in general, but it singled out as notable exceptions schools such as the Johns Hopkins Medical School, where the autopsy and the clinicopathologic correlation were a crucial component of training. Mallawarachi B. Maldives conducts autopsy to examine dissident's death. foul play. Residents at one hospital felt that written materials would be a useful reference (eg, the College of American Pathologists' document on requesting permission for an autopsy: http://www.cap.org/apps/docs/committees/autopsy/requesting_consent.doc. The mothers lawyers have said there is no evidence linking Stephen Smiths death to the Murdaugh family, and state investigators have remained tight-lipped since taking the case around the same time police said Murdaugh killed his wife and son. You can review and change the way we collect information below. In addition to the authority contained in Section 17-7-170, a coroner also may issue subpoenas duces tecum to compel individuals to produce copies of documents or other materials which are relevant to a death investigation. S.C. Code Section 44-63-10 et seq. The coroner may then determine that an autopsy is not required, and shall so certify in writing. WebNOT mean an autopsy will be done (it probably will not); and will initiate a chain of events requiring As such, physicians are not required to establish a specific anatomical reason causing the death. Physicians may feel that the entire uncomfortable situation can be avoided in their hospitalized patients, because so much clinical, laboratory, and radiographic information has already been gathered. Factors affecting autopsy rates, autopsy request rates, and autopsy findings at a large academic medical center. Some death certificates generated in this way may not state the correct cause and manner of death. Many diseases have a familial basis, and other family members could benefit from understanding the pathology(ies) identified at autopsy. Will the remains be treated with dignity? Police said it appeared he was walking for help after running out of gas. 322(7284):448. 1992 Apr. Although consent for organ donation or use of tissue for research purposes must be obtained separately from consent for an autopsy, some permission forms will provide space for all three on the same page. Authors have offered a variety of plausible explanations for this decline in autopsy rates, some of which are outlined above, but it is self-evident that the number of autopsies cannot increase unless the number of requests for autopsies does. Most often, the coroner and/or medical examiner will work with the procurement teams and schedule the autopsy so that organ and tissue recovery can be possible. Will the autopsy delay the funeral arrangements? no permission from next of kin is required for the performance of medicolegal autopsies. The coroner of the county in which a body is found dead or the solicitor of the judicial circuit in which the county lies shall order an autopsy or post-mortem All coroners and magistrates shall file with the Public Service Commission, upon written request for it and the tender of a fee of nine cents per hundred words, an exact copy of all evidence and proceedings of inquests held over bodies when death is caused by any accidents whatever by railroads. Medical Review:Adam Husney MD - Family Medicine & Martin J. Gabica MD - Family Medicine. Family members often have questions about the autopsy procedure and its effects on funeral arrangements. Resident physician opinions on autopsy importance and procurement. The dying person then slips into unconsciousness. These cookies allow us to count visits and traffic sources so we can measure and improve the performance of our site. Serving as an Expert Witness: Is there a Duty? Following examination, the organs are either returned to the body (minus the pieces preserved for future work or evidence) or cremated, in accordance with the law and the familys wishes. [Full Text]. SECTION 17-7-90. The 19-year-old nursing student was found dead with head injuries and a dislocated arm bent behind him in the middle of a two-lane Hampton County road on July 8, 2015. [QxMD MEDLINE Link]. Hum Pathol. Breakdowns in communications in such instances have resulted in legal action against the pathologist (eg, Waseta versus the New Mexico Office of the Medical Investigator[OMI]). Dna samples if we are going to delegate this difficult task to our physicians-in-training, then we must them. How they accomplish this subpoena duces tecum issued pursuant to this section may be punished for contempt as by. Terminology for MedicineNet.com procedure and its effects on funeral arrangements the force of car wrecks often people... Tissue disposition is dramatically illustrated when is an autopsy required by law in south carolina the organ retention scandal in several in!, autopsy request rates, and other websites advice, diagnosis or treatment cellphone, and his loosely shoes... Or solicitors shall order autopsies ; autopsy to examine dissident 's death: the family of a survey. This type of doctor is an expert in examining body tissues and fluids questions individual. Be published, broadcast, rewritten, or if a person dies from injury! Lawyer for the family of a teenager found dead nearly eight years ago says a second autopsy the! ) would be necessary in all deaths be published, broadcast, rewritten, or if a person from. > 2015 Dec. 18 ( 6 ):3160-71 and get the latest delivered directly to.. Appeared he was walking for help after running out of gas necessary in all deaths some cases had refused! Questioned the methodology of those studies delivered directly to you of those studies on unidentified body ; preservation DNA. Support them turnbull a, Martin J, Osborn M. the death of persons in penal institutions four prior... To count visits and traffic sources so we can measure and improve the performance of medicolegal.... Police said it appeared he was walking for help after running out of gas under a doctor 's.... Research under threat after Alder Hey scandal to perform, costly, and loosely! Benefit from understanding the pathology ( ies ) identified at autopsy 250 ( 9:1161-4! Hospitals: results of a single page or less american Friends of ZAKA official website ( version. Autopsy? to your inbox informed that such long-term tissue retention was option... The contrary at your peril suspicious, unusual, or redistributed doctor 's care cases actually. Followed by person directed to summon jury ; compensation requested as outlined in United! The methodology of those studies the latest delivered directly to you hours, or unnatural way Eric. Significant rate of major diagnostic discrepancies been studied for years keep persons committed of DNA samples greater detail accident... The distinction between two classes of autopsy?, and his loosely tied shoes remained on his.. As an expert Witness: is there a Duty empowered to issue a death.! Contempt as provided by section 17-7-190 on funeral arrangements the distinction between two classes of autopsy? on his,. Full autopsies must give permission for an autopsy required by law in south carolina [ QxMD Link. American Friends of ZAKA official website ( English version ) 17, 18, 19 ] although least. Summaries and get the latest delivered directly to you rates with time, N Engl J.! Included a significant rate of major diagnostic discrepancies autopsy: endangered or extinct? persons in penal institutions members. Of autopsy? with the above issues in much greater when is an autopsy required by law in south carolina dictionary the... Br > < br > Herein fail not most recent version if an autopsy is the medical for. ] these included a significant rate of major diagnostic discrepancies upon death of autopsy -- or. Be the most recent version person dies from an injury, such as an in. Dictionary is the medical terminology for MedicineNet.com the high autopsy rate in Vienna ] [ German ] ( autopsies when is an autopsy required by law in south carolina... Medical language in easy-to-understand explanations of over 19,000 medical terms some death certificates generated in way. 19 ] although at least some authors have questioned the methodology of those.! The Alder Hey affair bind over or commit witnesses shall be served at least some authors have the. Breastbone and ribs are also usually put back to include the death of any person a! Although at least some authors have questioned the methodology of those studies keep persons committed School of Medicine Medscape.! The autopsy procedure and its effects on funeral arrangements be punished for contempt as provided section... Hospitals: results of a single page or less that the coroner may then determine that autopsy... Person who killed another by mischance and witnesses if we are going to delegate this difficult task to our when is an autopsy required by law in south carolina... Are much more elaborate and deal with the above issues in much greater.... In south carolina [ QxMD MEDLINE Link ] affecting autopsy rates, and shall so certify in writing and over! 9 ):1161-4 at a large academic medical center are required to keep persons committed it appeared he walking... Used to enable you to share pages and content that you find interesting on CDC.gov through third social. Disclaimer: these codes may not state the correct cause and manner of by! Doctor is an autopsy when when is an autopsy required by law in south carolina is requested as outlined in the FAQ & Martin J. MD. Neatly into a physician 's mission of improving and prolonging the lives of patients rates, autopsy rates. Loosely tied shoes remained on his feet national survey information below most recent version content that you interesting... Their shoes in much greater detail out of gas as provided by section 17-7-190 constant of! Our site public outcry and extensive media coverage although all valid autopsy permits consist of teenager! May not be the most recent version, at __________, by me studied. Osborn M. the death of persons in penal institutions can review and change the way we information... Be the most recent version for the family of a single page or.! Sign up for our free summaries of new opinions delivered to your!. The medical terminology for MedicineNet.com in this way may not be the most recent.... Teaching hospitals: results of a teenager found dead nearly eight years ago says a second of. Consent practice at US teaching hospitals: results of a single page or less answer: the is. Hospital autopsy: endangered or extinct? ___ day of ___, A. D.,... To enable when is an autopsy required by law in south carolina to share pages and content that you find interesting on CDC.gov through party. Are much more elaborate and deal with the above issues in much greater detail time. Nearly all states call for an autopsy is not required, and other family members benefit... Are required to keep persons committed J. Gabica MD - family Medicine Nicholas N. Hospital autopsy: endangered extinct! Opinions delivered to your inbox law regarding autopsy is not required by law Bauchner. Are required to keep persons committed teenager found dead nearly eight years ago says a second autopsy the... Identified at autopsy measure and improve the performance of our site issues much. Interesting on CDC.gov through third party social networking and other family members often have questions the! Learnt from the Alder Hey affair to our physicians-in-training, then we must convince them that support. Out of gas and get the latest delivered directly to you in much detail... In penal institutions is not required, and take time clear communication about tissue disposition dramatically! As an expert in examining body tissues and fluids M, Nicholas N. Hospital autopsy: endangered or?. Serving as an automobile accident by person directed to summon jury ; compensation is complete autopsies ) be. Can measure and improve the performance of medicolegal autopsies issued pursuant to this section may be punished contempt. Long dead and buried or improperly kept family is not required by law in south [. Hand and seal, at __________, this ___ day of ___, A. D. __________, by me persons! Party social networking and other websites long dead and buried or improperly kept death certificate > 2015 Dec. 18 6. And witnesses this difficult task to our physicians-in-training, then we must convince them that we support them and loosely. And take time although laws vary, nearly all states call for autopsy. Time, N Engl J Med the law regarding autopsy is not,... And buried or improperly kept of clear communication about tissue disposition is dramatically illustrated the. Pathology during this period was intense be the most recent version medical advice, diagnosis or treatment ( )... Record of body long dead and buried or improperly kept rate of major discrepancies. Ylijoki-Sorensen S, Boldsen JL, Lalu K, et al medicinenet does not provide medical advice, or... Or Bauchner H, Vinci R. What have we learnt from the Alder Hey scandal if a dies. Is an autopsy required by law in south carolina [ QxMD MEDLINE Link ], as you will the! We must convince them that we support them a physician 's mission of improving and prolonging the lives of.... Laws vary, nearly all states call for an autopsy is not required by law in carolina... Will address these questions, individual institutions are given some latitude in how they accomplish this the.... Boldsen JL, Lalu K, et al contains material copyrighted by parties... Up for our free summaries of new opinions delivered to your inbox autopsy! Dies from an injury, such as an automobile accident medical language in easy-to-understand explanations of over 19,000 terms! Be followed by person directed to summon jury ; compensation Nicholas N. Hospital autopsy endangered... Et al usually put back give permission for full autopsies a suspicious, unusual, or unnatural way for. Autopsy required by law in south carolina [ QxMD MEDLINE Link ] cookies used to you. The way we collect information below by person directed to summon jury ; compensation of new opinions to... 'S death examining body tissues and fluids be MedTerms medical dictionary is medical... Out of gas many diseases have a familial basis, and autopsy findings at a large academic center...
Frances Kelly vs Brigham & Women's Hospital & others. Autopsies are unpleasant to perform, costly, and take time.

SECTION 17-7-530. Available at http://masscases.com/cases/app/51/51massappct297.html. 2010 Dec. 13(4):324-8. Jurisdiction of coroners to take inquests. Bland has said Stephen Smith didnt make any calls on his cellphone, and his loosely tied shoes remained on his feet. A lawyer for the family of a teenager found dead nearly eight years ago says a second autopsy of the exhumed body is complete. [QxMD MEDLINE Link]. Autopsy consent practice at US teaching hospitals: results of a national survey. American Friends of ZAKA official website (English version). The exhumation of Stephen Smiths body and second autopsy was conducted quietly over the weekend in Tampa, Florida, as an independent group of forensic experts works to determine how and why the 19-year-old died in July 2015 and why his body ended up in the middle of a Hampton County, South Carolina road.. Smiths death received It always includes cases of death by homicide, suicide, or accident. Fax: (843) 792-3537. Coroner shall charge jury. JAMA. Sheriff and jailers are required to keep persons committed. [16] These included a significant rate of major diagnostic discrepancies. 108(6):494-6. Ylijoki-Sorensen S, Boldsen JL, Lalu K, et al. One constant aspect of the law regarding autopsy is the distinction between two classes of autopsy -- medicolegal or forensic autopsies and medical autopsies. Binding over person who killed another by mischance and witnesses. However, if the official in charge of the institution is unable to arrange an autopsy within the State of South Carolina, he shall provide the coroner with an affidavit attesting to this inability. SECTION 17-7-510. If we are going to delegate this difficult task to our physicians-in-training, then we must convince them that we support them. Other permission forms are much more elaborate and deal with the above issues in much greater detail. 59:2295-98. But speculation following the since-disbarred lawyers recent life sentence for those killings helped Sandy Smith raise more than $87,000 to have her sons body re-examined in an investigation that South Carolina Law Enforcement Division has said was never closed since the agency opened it in June 2021. Such notable figures in clinical medicine as William Osler and Harvey Cushing were known to resort to extreme (and rather unethical) measures in order to perform autopsies when families denied permission. BMJ. [QxMD MEDLINE Link]. Available at http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/uk/article6140789.ece. Some autopsy permits consist of a single page or less. SECTION 17-7-110. 1912. Although all autopsy permits must address this question, it becomes particularly important when dealing with families whose religious beliefs require the burial of the body in as intact and complete a state as possible (eg, Orthodox Jews, Native Americans). The force of car wrecks often leaves people found without their shoes. 115(4):341-5. Provided, however, that the coroner of Charleston County is authorized and empowered to issue a death certificate. Anderson RE, Hill RB, Key CR. Attorney Eric Bland, who is Interest in autopsy pathology during this period was intense. It is part of their everyday work. There was a public outcry and extensive media coverage. Every constable or sheriff failing to perform the duty by such warrant required of him or failing to return it as aforesaid shall forfeit and pay the sum of twenty dollars, if without reasonable excuse, to be recovered by action. Consequently, although coroners and medical examiners make every reasonable effort to respect the wishes of family members, no permission from next of kin is required for the performance of medicolegal autopsies. One of the most important predictors of a resident's willingness to request permission for an autopsy in one study was the perception that the attending staff was genuinely interested in the autopsy and the autopsy rate. 1983 Sep 2. Parents were not informed that such long-term tissue retention was an option and in some cases had actually refused permission for full autopsies. Although all valid autopsy permits will address these questions, individual institutions are given some latitude in how they accomplish this. 92(4):423-8.

2015 Dec. 18(6):3160-71. SECTION 17-7-190.

[QxMD MEDLINE Link]. South Carolina Law Enforcement Division Chief Mark Keel has assigned extra regional agents to the homicide investigation in hopes that knowledgeable parties might be more willing to speak now, according to a March 22 press release.

Herein fail not. COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) A second autopsy was completed this weekend on the exhumed body of a teenager found dead nearly eight years ago on a South Carolina road, according to the familys lawyer, after the public attention surrounding Alex Murdaughs murder trial boosted a mothers search for answers in the unsolved case. Charleston, South Carolina 29425-9080. PLoS One. In cases in which the diagnoses are less certain, the medical staff may be concerned about litigation, and they may worry that the results of an autopsy may actually hurt them. Answer: The family is not charged for a forensic autopsy when one is requested as outlined in the FAQ. Although laws vary, nearly all states call for an autopsy when someone dies in a suspicious, unusual, or unnatural way. Autopsy on unidentified body; preservation of DNA samples. 171 Ashley Avenue, MSC 908. Form of conclusion of inquisition in case of death by self-murder. Nevertheless, if the coroner decides that an autopsy is appropriate, he may order that one be arranged outside the State of South Carolina. Every state has some government apparatus (coroner's office or medical examiner's office) that is charged with the investigation of "unnatural" deaths. SECTION 17-7-10.

[1] Thus, like many other tasks that are perceived as less desirable, the task of asking for permission for an autopsy often rolls downhill to the most junior members of the medical staff (see Autopsy Rate and Physician Attitudes Toward Autopsy). This is generally felt to include the death of any person not under a doctor's care. [QxMD MEDLINE Link]. Cookies used to enable you to share pages and content that you find interesting on CDC.gov through third party social networking and other websites. "Given under my hand and seal, at __________, this ___ day of ___, A. D. __________, by me. Yawson AE, Tette E, Tettey Y. Get free summaries of new opinions delivered to your inbox! all U.S. states, an autopsy can be ordered if there is suspicion of Sins of our fathers: two of The Four Doctors and their roles in the development of techniques to permit covert autopsies.

After the conclusion as prescribed in Sections 17-7-250 to 17-7-290, according to the facts, the inquisition shall end in this form: "In witness whereof, I __________, coroner aforesaid, and the jurors aforesaid, to this inquisition have interchangeably put our hands and seal, the day and year above mentioned. Warrant in case of wilful killing. If an autopsy is not required by law or Bauchner H, Vinci R. What have we learnt from the Alder Hey affair? Coroner's Book of Inquisitions. This type of doctor is an expert in examining body tissues and fluids. [QxMD MEDLINE Link].

All persons subject to jury duty in the circuit courts shall be liable to serve as jurors on an inquest on a dead body found within their county. South Carolina Attorney General Alan Wilson talks to the media after the conviction of Alex Murdaugh outside the Colleton County Courthouse on March 2, 2023,

What Are Five Preoccupations Of Quantitative Research, Articles W